Free US shipping on orders over $49|15% off any 3 jars|Questions? Call (781) 226-8208

Introducing a New Supplement to a Picky Cat

Cats notice everything in their bowl. A step-by-step approach to introducing powders and new foods to a skeptical cat without starting a hunger strike.

Gray and white cat eating from a sage green ceramic bowl

Dogs will eat almost anything you sprinkle on dinner. Cats are a different story. If you've ever watched your cat sniff a bowl, look at you with betrayal, and walk away, this one's for you.

Why cats are so particular

Cats rely heavily on smell to judge food, and many form strong preferences early in life. A new texture or aroma in a familiar bowl can be a big deal. That pickiness is normal — and with patience, most cats come around.

One important rule first

Never let a cat go without eating to "wait them out." Cats who stop eating for more than a day or two can develop serious liver problems. If your cat refuses food entirely, offer their regular meal without the supplement and call your vet if they still won't eat.

A slow, step-by-step approach

  1. Start tiny. Use a pinch — far less than a full serving — for the first few days.
  2. Use wet food. Powders blend in more easily. Mix thoroughly so there's no visible layer on top.
  3. Pick their favorite meal. Add it to the food they're most excited about, not the one they tolerate.
  4. Try a "topper" trick. Mix the powder into a teaspoon of something irresistible, like a lickable treat, and offer that first.
  5. Increase slowly. Every few days, add a little more until you reach the full serving.
  6. Warm it slightly. Room-temperature or barely warm wet food smells stronger and more appealing.

Which formulas suit cats?

Our powders — Digestion, Immunity and Skin & Coat — are formulated for both dogs and cats and are unflavored. Digestion has a mild, slightly sweet aroma from pumpkin that cats tend to accept most easily, so it's a good one to start with. Our soft chews are for dogs only.

Bonus: sneak in more water

Many cats don't drink enough. Mixing supplements into wet food with a spoonful of warm water is a simple way to add a little extra hydration at the same time.

Every cat is different. If yours has kidney disease, a urinary condition or takes daily medication, check with your veterinarian before adding any supplement.

JD
Jessica Dowdy
Founder of FurHealth, lifelong dog and cat person, based in Alliance, Ohio. This article is for general education and isn't veterinary advice.

Not sure where to start?

Answer four quick questions and we'll point you to the formula that fits your pet — plus 10% off your first order.